October 24, 2013

Review: The Cupcake Shoppe

 Our friends purchased half a dozen cupcakes for dessert from The Cupcake Shoppe, located in the Yonge and Eglinton area. I loved the little booklet included with the cupcakes and the colourful photos inside, but that's about it. 

This is going to be an honest review and I'm not holding back.

For a shop that charges  $2.85 per cupcake, $15.50 for a half dozen and $29.50 for a dozen, I expected better. Sure they're nice to look at, but holy cow are they totally lacking. You'll notice that I'll be using the words, dense, dry, flavourless and waxy repetitively and that's because they are. I wasn't the only one at the table sharing these opinions.

JAMES BROWN, chocolate cake with chocolate butter cream: The cake wasn't sweet enough, this coming from someone who doesn't have a sweet tooth. It was dense and although it looks deliciously chocolaty, it wasn't. Not one bit. Perhaps some vanilla or coffee could have helped in that department? The frosting was okay, nothing special. It was smooth.

RED VELVET, cream cheese frosting on red velvet cake: The cake flavour was okay. A generous ooookay. The texture was really dry and the cream cheese frosting could have been more cream cheese-y. Dry cakes need more frosting, right? This needed more frosting. A splash of vanilla wouldn't have hurt either. Oh and I almost choked eating this, as it absorbed any saliva I had in my mouth. It was like a red velvet sponge and I had to drink half a bottle of water to get through it.

CRUMMIE, cookies and cream butter cream on a chocolate cupcake. This cupcake was horrible. It was the worst out of them all. Same flavourless chocolate cake, but this time the frosting left a waxy film in your mouth. It felt like there was too much shortening in it; the mouth feel was off and  unpleasant. Not to mention it didn't taste like cookies and cream at all, since the butter cream just tasted sweet. Those little cookie/cake crumbs mixed in there are there for show. The only thing that makes this a cookies and cream cupcake is the cookie on top, which I doubt is made in house. No thanks!

STRAWBERRIES 'N CREAM, vanilla cake with vanilla and strawberry swirled butter cream. I didn't try this one, but it looks decent! But then again looks can be deceiving. At least it...looks moist and vanilla-y...and the frosting looks soft and fresh. There may or may not be fresh strawberries in it. For nearly $3 a cupcake, I would expect it.

FROST ME, vanilla frosting on marble cake. This one scared me as the frosting reminded me of Play-Doh and/or clowns. Neither of which I am keen on eating. The cake was firm and that's all I can say, I didn't try this one either.I had given up hope. (This one should have been a banana chocolate cake. Call it Banana Split!)

TRIPLE CHOCOLATE FUDGE, chocolate frosting on a chocolate cupcake. Um, where's the ~*triple chocolate*~? There's the cake and the frosting. Oh, wait- the five or seven mini- white chocolate chips makes for third chocolate fudgy-ness, right? I'd be prone to say NOPE, but I think that I'd be wrong. There was no gooey chocolatey injection in the cupcake, so I don't see how this is a triple chocolate fudge cupcake, at all. Same crappy chocolate cake, nothing impressive about the sweet frosting which was however the only fudge-y thing about this cupcake. I'm interested in knowing if it's made from scratch or if it's from a bucket.

Just a few flavours offered at The Cupcake Shoppe.

Would I suggest you spend your hard earned money at The Cupcake Shoppe? The answer is clearly, no. The cupcakes were a bit of a disappointment, especially coming from a store that is apparently "Toronto’s first and finest cupcake bakery". I certainly expected better tasting products, so I cry foul. Their swirls are cute, but it stops there. If you like pretty looking cakes, which no one will be eating, this is the place for you. Either Suzanne Cooper (owner) enjoys horribly textured and flavourless cupcakes or she needs to do some quality control at her shop! They say that their cupcakes are baked fresh daily, but are they left to sit out all day? Perhaps this is why their once fresh products are no longer fresh by the afternoon. Ick. Until then, I'd rather eat a slice of toast instead. At least it's supposed to be dry and I can butter it with real butter. Saves me on calories too.

Page Views


Hi, I'm Janetta from Toronto. I cook, bake and often veganize recipes. I photograph nearly everything and those photos will most likely end up being posted here. I've got a little black cat named Tank, who's really cute and a little bit nosy. You'll see a lot of photos of her too!

Contact me at: jubesandtank@gmail.com

Follow Me



home cooking Tank meat vegan vegetarian nature baking smart shopping flowers garden Toronto Richard dessert food pork beef chocolate noodles cake chicken eating out fruit ravine review Animals Birthday sick girl cosmetics dining out cookies Chinese BBQ Halloween cupcakes plants roasted potatoes Christmas bugs nailpolish pasta seafood steak cat drinks fish sandwich snack turkey Spring family ice cream raspberries recipe strawberries Park burger dog make up rice Indian bread free peanut butter pizza tomatoes CNE Kids Korean Thanksgiving Tulips afternoon tea buffet movies online shopping soup vanilla video birds coffee kale lemon pancakes pumpkin ribs sprinkles winter Autumn Barca Mother's Day Rich Star Wars Valentine's Day Vietnamese breakfast death sale scones sushi trees Japanese boots burgers gardening hot and spicy macro nuts seedlings sweet potatoes toys vegetarian food festival wraps Brick Works Chanukah DIY Easter Instagram Katie Passover art bee brunch bunny caramel cranberries curry donuts downtown duck herbs knitting lamb lobster pool raccoon red velvet spiders tacos Caribbean Chinese New Year Dragon Pearl Edwards Gardens Father's Day Gardien George Foreman Grill Greek Lens Baby Lola St. Jacobs Summer Thai all you can eat beaches books candy cheese clothing coconut crafting dumplings eggs infinity scarf mashed potatoes muffins oatmeal peking duck pesto pie portrait salmon samosas smoothie spectacles tofu tree vet America Canada Day Canon 50mm Canon T2i Comic Con Cuisinart Keurig Markham Music Ohio T1i ants apples bagels baking with beauty box bruschetta camera lens cereal cheese cake cinnamon cream cheese custom dragon fly ducks eye farm fireworks french toast fries frozen garage sale green tea hair care honey horses hot dogs hotel king crab laundry limes moon picnic popcorn rain rapini road trip salsa samples sauce scary skin care steam buns vega vegan. vegetarian weekend zoo 35mm Amaris Atticus Canon 55-250mm CoverGirl Disney Earth Day Five Guys Greenies Ikea Italian L'oreal Matt and Nat Melitta Mum Nikon P5100 Purex Rammstein Revlon Richard. vegan Rosh Hashanah Salad King Sci-Fi Shanghai Singapre Skinny Cow Spirng Starbucks Tank Girl Whittamore's farm Winston bag basil bees boats brownies brushes bubble tea bubbles butter tart butterscotch cake mix cookies camping candied carob cars cashew cheese casserole celebrity chicken. meat chili chipmunk cicada circus clown compost contest cookie couscous crochet deep fried deer dehydrator doves dreams eating out. duck elephants face mask fail fairy shrimp fassbender fly gadget granola green beans ground cherries gum hair dye hockey home cooking. chili home cooking. meat juicing kettle corn lawyer left overs mango marshmallow matzo meringue middle eastern nature. bugs. animals olive ornaments parfait peppers piano play time polenta pomegranate prints pumpkins racoon regrowing shopping snacks snail snowflakes soy squares steak. beef stew surprise travel upick veal venison waffles wallpaper wasp wedding worm yogurt yorkshire pudding youtube